Quote Originally Posted by tealblue View Post
Hey on a side note in verse 32 are you saying that moses didn't give them manna and it was actually something else because verse 31 is clear that moses did give them manna and they ate it. Jesus is only saying that the manna didn't come from heaven like the bread that he soon will.
I'll get to your previous post, probably tomorrow. But this is a short answer. Moses didn't give them "the bread from heaven". The words "from heaven" need to be included. But in actuality, Moses didn't give them the manna either. God provided the manna. Moses merely told the people about what God was going to provide.