Both 1 and 2 are correct. As I said above you are taking the original meaning of the quote to mean something completely different than what they meant. But out of fairness to you tell me what you think they meant then perhaps we can sort this out.Of course... Everybody does, it's the same merry-go-round ride he always creates.
His MO is very simple yet an effective obfuscation tool.
As I noted the other day on the other thread, Billyray will create two separate and unrelated arguments which he'll mesh into one.
Only in this case instead of two questions or arguments, he has two separate answers that he has meshed together to your one question, "how can the Father and Son be of one substance?"
His answers are;
1. The Father and Christ are uncreated.
2. The Father does not have a body of flesh and bones, the Son does.